HARD COAL COMPARISON, FUEL OIL, NATURAL GAS AND LIQUID GAS AS FUELS USED IN BOILER ROOMS

Hard coal is a solid fuel, which in itself is a clear distinction from the other three fuels, being liquids. The course and conditions of burning solid fuels differ from these, which occur during the combustion of liquid fuels. Therefore, hard coal has certain characteristics (even low maintenance requirements or limited possibilities to control the combustion process), which other fuels are deprived of.
The table lists the advantages and disadvantages of individual fuels, the list is not exhaustive.

Coal
Benefits Disadvantages
• Good price

• Domestic fuel

• Easy transport and storage (it can be transported and stored even in paper bags)

• Low investment costs

• Low handling requirements

• High emission of pollutants

• Dust in boiler rooms

• Limited possibilities to control the combustion process (solid fuel - poor mixing of fuel with air)

• Manual operation of the boiler room (personnel costs)

• Need to remove ash and slag

Heating oil
Benefits Disadvantages
• Low emission of pollutants

• Precise control of the combustion process

• Automated boiler room service

• Easy transport

• High price (excise)

• Strategic fuel not available in Poland (the price depends on the geopolitical situation)

• Significant investment costs

• Risk of local environmental pollution due to leakage

• High requirements for the tightness of storage tanks

Natural gas
Benefits Disadvantages
• Very low emission of pollutants

• Precise control of the combustion process

• Automated boiler room service

• Easy transport (within the range of the gas network)

• No need to store at the customer's place

• Fuel imported from abroad (ok. 2/3 demand)

• Forecasted price increase in the coming years

• Significant investment costs of the gas network

• Availability limited by the range of the gas network

• Danger of explosion

Liquefied gas
Benefits Disadvantages
• Very low emission of pollutants

• Precise control of the combustion process

• Automated boiler room service

• Availability dependent on natural gas and crude oil supplies to refineries

• Significant investment costs

• Transport in sealed pressurized tanks

• Necessity to store in pressurized tanks near the boiler room

• Limitations related to the design and location of the boiler room

When selecting the fuel, you should think first, whether it should be hard coal, or one of the other fuels. In the case of hard coal, you can choose a traditional boiler or use a modern quick-disconnect boiler with an automatic fuel feeder.
The use of a traditional coal-fired boiler is supported by lower investment costs (not very advanced technologies are used in this type of boilers) and lower fuel expenses. The main disadvantage, however, is the inability to use automation systems. For small boiler rooms, operated by household members, admittedly there are no personnel costs, but in larger venues, requiring employment of an employee, it may be, that the savings will be illusory, because the cost of fuel will need to be paid for servicing with derivatives.
Modern designs of low-power coal boilers have solutions that reduce service time (refilling the charcoal container is necessary once every few days). In addition, the design of the hearth (for example. retort hearth) and automatic fuel feeder (for example. screw feeder) allow to automate the operation of the boiler room. The investment cost of such a solution is, however, comparable, and even higher than the cost of a gas or oil boiler room.
By choosing to burn hard coal, however, be aware, that it is associated with the emission of a significant amount of pollutants into the environment. In the case of boiler rooms with powers above 200 kW, this means additional costs incurred on charges for discharging pollutants into the atmosphere. Smaller heat sources do not require such charges, but here it must be taken into account, whether the emission from coal combustion will not be burdensome for the owners of neighboring properties.
Generally, the use of hard coal is justified in the case of small domestic boiler houses, located outside an area with intensive development, when you want to save on investment and operating costs. However, you should be aware of this, that it is connected with the need to independently operate the boiler room. In other cases, it is advisable to use a different fuel.
Tam, where there is access to the gas network, the best solution is to design a natural gas-fired boiler house. There is no need to put up tanks for fuel and take care of its adequate supply. Besides, natural gas is still more attractive in terms of price than heating oil and LPG.
Liquefied gas and heating oil will be used in the regions, which are not connected to the gas network. If there is a possibility of connecting and using natural gas in the future, these liquid gas fired boiler houses can be easily adapted to burn natural gas.